Triumphs and Tragedies in the Founding of the Republic
Mem. Ed. $6.99
Pub. Ed. $27.50
You pay $1.00
From the opening shots fired at Lexington and Concord in April 1775 to the 1803 purchase of the Louisiana territory, an acquisition that both vastly expanded the size of the young republic and assured her future mastery of the continent, the birth of the United States was a tumultuous, bitterly contested affair. Even the leading lights of the Founding couldn’t agree on the best course for their bold experiment in liberty and republican government. Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton, to take just a few instances out of many, disagreed bitterly over matters including banking, states rights, standing armies, and slavery.
So how did the United States come to exist? In a soaring narrative that stretches from the modest beginnings of the rebellion to the give-and-take of the Constitutional Convention and the uncertain early years of the new republic, Joseph Ellis’ magnificent American Creation reveals precisely how it was done. “[It] is a story,” Ellis writes, “about tragedy as well as triumph, indeed about their mutual and inextricable coexistence.”
Ironically, Ellis continues, some of the Founders’ most impressive and inventive solutions actually closed off options that would have solved other key problems. “By circumscribing federal power, especially at the executive level,” he notes, the Constitution greatly limits the risk of domestic despotism, but it also “made it virtually impossible to…reach a just accommodation with the Native Americans.”
And then there is the Founding generation’s most infamous compromise: slavery. To abolish the “peculiar institution,” as figures like New York’s irrepressible Gouverneur Morris demanded, would have totally alienated the South. Yet to explicitly sanction human bondage would have provoked a firestorm of outrage in the North. Indeed, as no less an authority than James Madison recorded in his published Notes on the 1787 Constitutional Convention, “the great division of interests did not lie between the large & small States; It lay between the Northern & Southern.” Thus the Constitution speaks of “other persons” in its three-fifths clause, not slaves, which left the matter to be resolved by a future generation and a brutal civil war.
Employing the same dazzling narrative gift and mastery of source material that defines his acclaimed Founding Brothers, American Sphinx, and His Excellency, Joseph Ellis gives us the true story of the American Founding—including the many false starts, dreadful mistakes, and unsavory compromises that have since shaped our politics and society.
Hardcover: 304 pages
Publisher: Alfred A. Knopf, Inc./Random House ( October 30, 2007 )
Item #: 99-5814
ISBN: 9780307263698
Product Dimensions: 6.25 x 9.25 x 0.76 inches
Product Weight: 18.0 ounces

An OK read, but Ellis' work has been on a clear downward spiral since his "outing" for fraud some years ago. One would think that Ellis would try harder to regain the reader's trust. If you purchase this one, make sure you check the citations carefully.
Reviewer: Kirs P
Great Comprehensive book. As a High School of AP US Govt and US History this is a great book it gives a comprehensive overview of the major palyers and events of the development of our early republic. It also sumerizes earlier works bythe auther and should be used as a stepping stone to Ellis other books
Reviewer: Bernard S
Ellis' latest is an informative, entertaining book. It chronicles key episodes, personalities, and policies of the first decades of the noble experiment in self-rule, the United States of America. Ellis does capture the fragility of those early years, that the continued existence of the US often hung by a tenuous thread. The chapters, some a bit better than others, can be read individually, as essays, or as a whole book. Much of the material isn't new, found in Ellis' previous books. But there are many nuggets that are new, adding to the attraction and readability of the book. It was interesting to read, in the introduction, Ellis' indictment of many current historians of American history, which I find to be on the money. Some of the writing does seem a bit stilted, not quite up to the quality of Ellis' usual writing. One thing that was curious, if not somewhat perturbing, was Ellis' frequent use of "perhaps," as if he were hedging.
Reviewer: Karen M
In general, the book was good, but the editing poor. Too many run on sentences for this level of scholarship. More detail on the Adams-Jefferson relationship and election would have added greatly to the value of the work.
Reviewer: Gary R
I found the book to be wordy and not very well proofread. In the intro to the book Ellis talks about the recent interest in the founders and this book appears to have been rushed to print in order to cash in on that popularity. Too many filler words, and sentences, far too many sentences and indeed paragraphs that began with a conjunction. I found the book to be disappointing because it was written by Ellis. Having read American Sphinx and His Excellency, I was expecting better.
Reviewer: Raymond S